Former Catalans Dragons player Jerome Guisset has weighed in on the recent appointment of Steve McNamara as the new coach of Hull FC, offering a nuanced perspective on the move. While he expresses enthusiasm for McNamara's potential impact, Guisset also highlights his disappointment in Hull FC's handling of the 2026 season.
Guisset believes that McNamara's success at Catalans Dragons, where he led the team to a Challenge Cup victory, a Super League Leaders Shield, and two Grand Final appearances, is a testament to his ability to transform a club's 'DNA'. However, he criticizes Hull FC's early season exit, suggesting that the club has 'waved the white flag' and forgotten about the current campaign. This, he argues, is particularly disappointing for a team with a large budget, high attendance figures, and a massive fan base.
The former player and coach emphasizes the importance of a club's commitment to its fans, especially for a team like Hull FC. He questions the decision to part ways with John Cartwright, suggesting that it wasn't handled well. Guisset's perspective highlights the tension between a club's short-term and long-term goals, and the potential consequences of prioritizing one over the other.
Despite his reservations, Guisset acknowledges McNamara's potential to bring success to Hull FC. He praises McNamara's ability to immerse himself in a new culture and transform a team, suggesting that his foreign background and lack of familiarity with French culture didn't hinder his impact at Catalans Dragons. Guisset's comments reflect a belief that McNamara's appointment could be a turning point for Hull FC, but only if the club can address its current challenges effectively.
In conclusion, Guisset's analysis provides a critical yet insightful perspective on the McNamara appointment. It underscores the complexities of managing a sports club and the delicate balance between short-term setbacks and long-term success. As Hull FC looks to rebuild and refocus, Guisset's words offer a reminder of the importance of fan engagement and the potential for a coach to make a significant impact, even in the face of early season struggles.
